Background
The case concerned a self-employed haulier who relied on three subcontractors for the transport of professional printers. The Belgian tax authorities questioned whether the services invoiced by those subcontractors had actually been performed. They therefore disallowed the corresponding expenses for personal income tax purposes and denied the related input VAT deduction. In addition, they imposed a 50% tax surcharge and a 200% VAT penalty, considering that the taxpayer had acted with fraudulent intent.
What the Court decided
The Court agreed that the taxpayer had failed to sufficiently substantiate the reality of the services. Among other things, the invoices issued by the three subcontractors were almost identical in form, supporting documentation regarding the invoiced amounts was missing, proof of payment could not be produced and there was no record of commercial correspondence with the subcontractors. The Court therefore upheld both the disallowance of the expenses and the denial of the VAT deduction.
Crucially, however, the Court held that failure to meet the burden of proof for the deduction does not automatically amount to fraud. Certain elements of the case indicated that the taxpayer and his wife genuinely believed that the subcontracting activities were being carried out through the companies concerned. Their names or abbreviations appeared on consignment notes and in emails relating to the deliveries. Moreover, an intermediary had arranged the assignments, provided the bank account details for payment and repeatedly pressed for payment.
The Court accepted that the taxpayer had acted with a considerable degree of negligence and carelessness. He had accepted invoices without adequate supporting details, had not investigated the companies or their directors and had made payments to accounts controlled by an intermediary. This may have facilitated fraud committed by third parties. But none of this was sufficient to establish that the taxpayer himself had acted with fraudulent intent. The personal income tax surcharge was therefore reduced from 50% to 10%. Applying the same reasoning for VAT purposes, the Court reduced the VAT penalty from 200% to 10%.
Why does this judgment matter?
The judgment draws a clear distinction between two separate questions, each governed by its own burden of proof.
On the one hand, a taxpayer claiming the deduction of expenses must demonstrate that the relevant conditions for deduction are met. If the taxpayer fails to do so, the expenses or input VAT may be disallowed. On the other hand, if the tax authorities seek to impose a penalty on the basis of fraud, it is for the tax authorities to establish not only the existence of a tax infringement, but also the requisite fraudulent intent on the part of the taxpayer concerned. Failure by the taxpayer to substantiate a deduction cannot, by itself, supply that proof.
This distinction is particularly important because tax surcharges and VAT penalties of this nature may qualify as criminal sanctions for the purposes of the European Convention on Human Rights, given their punitive and deterrent character. As a result, fundamental criminal-law safeguards apply, including the presumption of innocence and the principle of personal criminal responsibility.
The presumption of innocence prevents the tax authorities from effectively reversing the burden of proof by requiring a taxpayer who cannot establish the deductibility of an expense to also prove that he did not act fraudulently. Likewise, the principle of personal criminal responsibility means that fraud committed by a third party cannot simply be attributed to the taxpayer. The tax authorities must establish the taxpayer's own involvement, knowledge or intentional participation.
Practical takeaways
The judgment is particularly relevant where the tax authorities seek to move from a finding that expenses or input VAT have not been sufficiently substantiated to an allegation of fraud. These are two distinct issues. A taxpayer may have been negligent, careless or simply unable to discharge the burden of proof regarding a deduction without necessarily having acted fraudulently.
Where substantial penalties are imposed on the basis of fraud, taxpayers should therefore carefully examine whether the authorities have actually established the required fraudulent intent in the taxpayer's own conduct, rather than merely relying on the underlying tax irregularity or on the conduct of third parties.
Contact
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact the advisers listed below or your usual Loyens & Loeff adviser.
Downloads
Fraude wordt niet vermoed: rechtbank herleidt belastingverhoging en btw-boete tot 10 % bij gebrek aan bewijs van fraude