You are here:
26 February 2019 / article

AG Wahl opines that the principle of economic continuity also applies when the EU cartel prohibition is privately enforced

On 6 February 2019, AG Wahl delivered an opinion in case C-724/17.

Banking Finance

 (link

In his opinion, Wahl advises the European Court of Justice (ECJ) to rule that the principle of economic continuity also applies when a private party claims damages in relation to a cartel so that such party may seek compensation from a company that has continued the economic activity of a cartel participant.

Should the ECJ follow the opinion, such approach may have a big impact on the liability of companies that have continued the economic activity of a cartel participant.

The case and the opinion of AG Wahl

In the case at hand, three companies were involved in a Finnish cartel that operated in the asphalt market between 1994 and 2002. However, these companies have since been dissolved in voluntary liquidation procedures and their sole shareholders have acquired their subsidiaries’ assets and continued their economic activities. The referring Finnish court asks the ECJ to answer the question whether or not these shareholders may be held liable for damages caused by these subsidiaries.

In the opinion, AG Wahl reasons that actions for antitrust damages form an integral part of the enforcement of EU competition law. AG Wahl deems it untenable that the concept of ‘undertaking’ would be interpreted in a more restrictive manner in private enforcement proceedings as in public enforcement proceedings. As such, AG Wahl advocates that ‘undertaking’ should be interpreted the same as in public enforcement proceedings, which also entails – in the case at hand – that companies that have continued the economic activity of a cartel participant are liable in private enforcement proceedings.

Competition Litigation Team

Our Competition Litigation Team consists of litigation and competition law experts and provides integrated strategic advise as to how to limit liability for competition law infringements. Please do not hesitate to contact us should you require any guidance in this respect.



Two decrees relating to new legislation on collective action

Act on Collective Damages in Class Actions and Class Action Register in effect as of 1 January 2020. read more
French payroll taxes as of 1 January 2019

Important judgments in Dutch air cargo proceedings

On 1 May 2019, the Amsterdam district court rendered three important judgments in the air cargo cartel litigation cases, in which claimants seek compensation... read more
JCPOA WorldTradeControls

Principle of economic continuity

On 14 March 2019, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) ruled in a preliminary ruling that shareholders that have acquired all shares of subsidiaries that participated... read more